
The Lexow Commission Exposes Police Brutality and Corruption
Clip: Episode 2 | 8m 40sVideo has Closed Captions
In 1894, the Lexow Commission forms to investigate corruption and police brutality among the NYPD.
Fifty years after New York formed the country's first police department, a commission, headed by New York senator Clarence Lexow, forms to investigate the force. The commission finds rampant evidence of police brutality and corruption at all levels of the police. Theodore Roosevelt promises to reform the force, but his reforms are quickly overturned when he moves to higher office.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

The Lexow Commission Exposes Police Brutality and Corruption
Clip: Episode 2 | 8m 40sVideo has Closed Captions
Fifty years after New York formed the country's first police department, a commission, headed by New York senator Clarence Lexow, forms to investigate the force. The commission finds rampant evidence of police brutality and corruption at all levels of the police. Theodore Roosevelt promises to reform the force, but his reforms are quickly overturned when he moves to higher office.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship♪ Voice: It appears that the police formed a separate and highly privileged class, armed with the authority and the machinery for oppression and punishment, but practically free themselves from the operation of the criminal law.
Clarence Lexow.
Narrator: In 1894, 50 years after New York City had created the country's first police department, Republicans in the state legislature, led by Senator Clarence Lexow, formed a commission to investigate corruption in the department.
Chief Thomas Byrnes and his officers found themselves at the center of a political storm.
The Lexow Commission in 1894 is the first instance where there is a massive investigation into police brutality and police corruption.
Narrator: The Commission wanted to use the green goods game to demonstrate the prevalence of police corruption, but they needed an insider to explain how the scam worked.
They subpoenaed George Appo and forced him to testify.
For three hours, he described what he called "police grafting."
Voice: You are well known to the detectives and policemen as being engaged in the green goods business?
[John W. Goff] Voice: Yes, sir.
If I passed by any police and tried to pick a pocket, they would see me pretty quick, but if I passed by them with a green goods victim, they bow and look and all that sort of thing.
[George Appo] Voice: They bow to you?
[Clarence Lexow] Yes, sir; I saw one at the Grand Central depot the other day.
Narrator: The Commission heard testimony from people who ran legitimate businesses-- boot-blacks, fruit vendors, and grocers.
Police demanded bribes from them, too, and beat those who refused to pay.
Gilfoyle: They demonstrate the existence of a vast, informal economy and a network that extends into all neighborhoods of the city, and the profitability of this underground economy extends into the millions of dollars, largely protected by the New York City Police.
Narrator: The hearings also exposed the hold that Democratic political bosses in Tammany Hall had over the police department.
To keep their patrons in power, officers stuffed ballot boxes and assaulted Republican voters on election day.
On the stand, Chief Thomas Byrnes did not deny that corruption existed, but said he lacked the power to do anything about it.
The Lexow Commission concluded that the police were guilty of "oppression, fraud, trickery, and crime."
One reporter called the New York Police "criminals in uniform."
A few months later, a Progressive New York Republican named Theodore Roosevelt became president of the Board of Police Commissioners, promising to reform and professionalize the department.
Voice: The public may rest assured that so far as I am concerned, there will be no politics in the department.
All appointments and promotions will be made for merit only, and without regard to political or religious considerations.
We are all activated by the desire to so regulate this department that it will earn the respect and confidence of the community.
Theodore Roosevelt.
Bratton: That early history of policing was shaped by a lot of brutality, a lot of racism, a lot of violence, a lot of corruption, a lot of political corruption.
And Teddy Roosevelt was credited with bringing about a lot of reforms to those negative elements of policing.
Narrator: Roosevelt hired 1,700 more officers, introduced bicycle squads, and demanded that liquor laws be enforced.
He fired hundreds of officers for dereliction of duty, including some who had been accused of brutality and graft by the Lexow Commission, and he forced Thomas Byrnes to resign.
But police reform did not last long.
Roosevelt left New York for Washington, D.C.
Some of the officers he fired were reinstated with back pay, and nothing was done to curtail the use of the third degree.
Thomas Byrnes lived the rest of his life in great comfort.
He had become a very wealthy man, thanks to investments made for him by Wall Street financiers to whom he had been of service.
Meanwhile, a theater producer who was producing a melodrama about life in the criminal underworld, called "In the Tenderloin" offered George Appo a starring role.
Every night, he reenacted the green goods game onstage.
Audiences were thrilled to see Appo and several other real criminals perform, and the show was a hit.
After a brief run in New York, it went on a national tour.
Gilfoyle: "In the Tenderloin" represents what critics call "Freak Drama"-- that individuals that were associated with deviant activities suddenly were being allowed to perform onstage-- in some ways in very idealized, dramatic ways that made the audience sympathize with the criminal.
Narrator: Before long, other famous outlaws started appearing on other stages, including Jesse James' brother Frank.
After the tour, when George Appo returned to New York, he was harassed and assaulted by police officers, who "feared he knew too much," he said, "about their crooked dealings."
His underworld associates attacked him, too.
Gilfoyle: His lawyer realized that it was likely that he would get killed by his former associates in the green goods game.
And a way to protect him was to have him declared insane.
Narrator: On December 24, 1896, Appo was sent to the Matteawan State Hospital for the Criminally Insane.
Voice: When I had been there about three weeks, I was surprised, one afternoon, by my unfortunate father entering the ward and walking over to where I was seated, reading a book.
He began to spring his insane delusions about his great wealth, and that he was the Commander of the Laws of Nature and was going to blow up all the prisons and, with his army, exterminate all keepers and doctors in them.
He then left to attend to his work in the Imbecile Ward.
[George Appo] Narrator: Quimbo Appo had spent decades behind bars, and his mental health had steadily deteriorated.
At Matteawan, the staff deemed him too dangerous ever to be released.
He would die there at 90, decades after his sentence had expired, and was buried on the grounds in an unmarked grave.
In 1899, George Appo was declared sane and released.
He was determined, he said, to "break away from the crooked life" for good.
He worked as a handyman in a church and an undercover investigator of opium dens for a Progressive reform organization.
His colleagues there encouraged him to write down the story of his remarkable life.
It was not published until after his death, but his memoir was one of the first accounts of life in the underworld written by someone who lived it.
Voice: In conclusion of this truthful statement of my life up to the present time, I am glad to be able to say that for nearly 18 years, I have lived an honorable life, and for several of these recent years, I have had steady employment.
A criminal can be reformed not through fear of brutal prison discipline, but by a kind and encouraging word and a friendly act.
[George Appo] Narrator: George Appo died of natural causes in 1930 at the age of 73.
An obituary called him "the finest crook that ever turned a new leaf."
Clara Sheldon Smith's stunning mug shots
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 1m 53s | Photographer Clara Sheldon Smith captures hundreds of mugshots in the early 20th century. (1m 53s)
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 5m 37s | The American public grapples with the question of if criminals are born or made. (5m 37s)
The Execution of Roxalana Druse
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 2m 34s | In 1887, the botched hanging of Roxalana Druse causes Americans to rethink the death penalty. (2m 34s)
The Federal Government vs. Indigneous Justice
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 4m 45s | After a Lakota leader is murdered, the federal government overrules the tribe's resolution. (4m 45s)
The Green Goods Game: The Most Devious Scam in America
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 7m 42s | Unable to find legal work, George Appo turns to a devious scam, the green goods game, to make money. (7m 42s)
How Racism and Eugenics Impacted the Criminal Justice System
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 3m 22s | As millions of immigrants flood to the United States, the popularity of the eugenics movement grows. (3m 22s)
Inspector Thomas Byrnes and the Evolution of Policing
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 11m 38s | Inspector Thomas Byrnes reinvents policing tactics in the 19th century using brutal methods. (11m 38s)
Lawyer Clarence Darrow Steps Up to Defend the Sweet Family
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 11m 10s | The legendary lawyer Clarence Darrow defends the Sweet family in their murder trial case. (11m 10s)
The Police Clash with Bootleggers Over Prohibition
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 5m 27s | Prohibition creates a black market for alcohol, leaving police struggling with enforcement. (5m 27s)
The Story of the Sweet Family and Housing Segregation
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 8m 53s | A white mob gathers to force the Sweet family into fleeing their new house in Detroit. (8m 53s)
Suffragists Tell the Stories of Incarcerated Women
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 6m 26s | Suffragist Kate Richards O'Hare details the experiences of the women she meets while incarcerated. (6m 26s)
Thomas Mott Osborne Brings Reform to Sing Sing Prison
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 10m 39s | After experiencing being imprisoned, Thomas Mott Osborne dedicates himself to reforming Sing Sing. (10m 39s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...




























